St. Louis Cardinals. – The Rule 5 Draft stands out as one of the more unique and intriguing mechanisms in Major League Baseball, setting it apart from other major professional sports leagues. Unlike traditional drafts that focus on amateur talent entering the professional ranks, this process gives teams the opportunity to acquire certain players already within other organizations. Specifically, clubs can select eligible players who have been left unprotected on another team’s roster, offering those players a potential pathway to the major leagues through a new organization.
Despite how interesting and potentially impactful this system can be, the Rule 5 Draft tends to fly under the radar compared to other MLB events. One of the main reasons it doesn’t receive as much attention is due to the strict conditions attached to any player chosen. If a team selects a player in the Rule 5 Draft, that player must remain on the selecting team’s 40-man roster for the entirety of the upcoming season.
If the team is unable or unwilling to keep the player at that level, they cannot simply send him down to the minors like they would with most players. Instead, the player must be offered back to his original organization. This requirement creates a significant challenge, as teams must carefully consider whether a player is ready to contribute at the big-league level for a full season.
Because of this roster restriction, many Rule 5 selections end up being short-term experiments rather than long-term additions. Teams may take a chance on a player with intriguing upside, but if that player struggles or if roster needs change, it can quickly become difficult to justify keeping him on the active roster. As a result, a number of players selected in the draft ultimately find their way back to their original teams after brief stints elsewhere.
MORE: Cardinals Officially Shake Up Bullpen, Responded With Perfect Roster Move
That was recently the case for the New York Yankees, who saw one of their Rule 5 picks return to his former organization after only a short time in the Bronx. The player, who had been selected with the hope that he could carve out a role on the major league roster, was unable to stick under the constraints of the Rule 5 system. Rather than continuing to occupy a roster spot, the Yankees were forced to send him back to the St. Louis Cardinals, the club from which he had originally been taken.
This situation highlights both the opportunity and the difficulty that come with the Rule 5 Draft. On one hand, it gives players who might otherwise be overlooked a chance to prove themselves at the highest level.
On the other hand, it places teams in a tough position, requiring them to balance development potential with the immediate needs of a competitive roster. In the end, while the Rule 5 Draft may not always generate headlines, it remains an important and fascinating part of how MLB teams build and manage their rosters.
Cardinals return Cade Winquest from the Yankees
Multiple reports, including an official announcement from the New York Yankees organization, confirmed that the club has returned right-handed pitcher Cade Winquest to the St. Louis Cardinals as of Monday. The move effectively ends a brief stint in the Yankees’ system that began just a few months earlier and underscores the unique challenges that come with being selected in the Rule 5 Draft.
Winquest’s journey to this point has been somewhat unconventional. Back on December 10, during the annual Rule 5 Draft, the Yankees made the decision to purchase his contract from the Cardinals organization. That selection was notable for a couple of reasons.
MORE: “Absolutely Sad” Red Sox Lose 26-Year-Old Best Slugger
For one, it marked the Yankees’ first participation in the Rule 5 Draft since 2011, signaling a shift—at least temporarily—in their roster-building strategy. Rather than relying solely on trades, free agency, or internal development, the Yankees chose to take a chance on a player who had yet to reach the major leagues but possessed intriguing upside.
The interest in Winquest was not something that developed overnight. In fact, the Yankees had reportedly been monitoring him as far back as the 2022 MLB Draft. At that time, however, he ultimately ended up with the Cardinals, who added him to their system and began working on his development. Despite not landing him initially, New York maintained its interest, which ultimately led to his selection in the Rule 5 Draft a couple of years later.
The premise behind drafting Winquest made logical sense from the Yankees’ perspective. The Rule 5 Draft is specifically designed to give opportunities to players who might be blocked within their current organizations.
It allows teams to select eligible players who are not protected on a 40-man roster, with the caveat that the selecting team must keep that player on its major league roster for the entire season or risk losing him. For the Yankees, Winquest represented a potential low-cost, high-upside addition—a pitcher with enough raw talent to possibly carve out a role if given the right opportunity.
Following his selection, Winquest remained with the Yankees throughout spring training. This period served as his first extended opportunity to showcase his abilities within the organization and to compete for a spot on the major league roster.
However, the results he produced during that time were less than ideal. Over the course of 10 innings in spring training action, Winquest allowed 13 hits and surrendered eight earned runs. Those numbers alone painted a picture of inconsistency and suggested that he struggled to find his rhythm on the mound.
MORE: Mets Officially Cut Ties With Veteran Reliever in Surprise Move
Perhaps more surprising than the overall stat line was his susceptibility to the long ball. In those same 10 innings, Winquest gave up three home runs. This stood out as particularly unusual given his track record. Historically, he had not been known as a pitcher who was easily hit for power.
His profile typically leaned more toward limiting hard contact, so seeing him give up multiple home runs in such a small sample size raised questions about what might have been going wrong. Whether it was mechanical issues, pitch location problems, or simply the adjustment to a new environment, something clearly wasn’t clicking.
While the home runs were unexpected, another aspect of his performance was less surprising. Control has been an area of concern for Winquest throughout his development, and that issue appeared again during his time with the Yankees.
Walks continued to be a problem, contributing to his struggles and putting additional pressure on him during outings. When a pitcher is both allowing hits and issuing free passes, it becomes increasingly difficult to escape innings unscathed, and that seemed to be the case for Winquest during spring training.
Ultimately, the Yankees were faced with a decision. Given the requirements of the Rule 5 Draft, they would have needed to carry Winquest on their major league roster throughout the season in order to retain his rights.
Based on his spring performance and the team’s overall roster considerations, they opted not to do so. Earlier this month, the Yankees designated Winquest for assignment, a move that effectively initiated the process of returning him to his original organization if no other team claimed him.
MORE: Diamondbacks Made Another Addition, Signed Right-Handed Pitcher
As it turned out, Winquest cleared waivers and was subsequently sent back to the Cardinals. According to Cardinals reporter Jeff Jones, he has been assigned to the Triple-A level following his return. This placement allows him to continue his development in a familiar system while working to refine the aspects of his game that need improvement.
From a broader perspective, this transaction may not generate significant headlines, especially when compared to blockbuster trades or high-profile signings. However, it still holds importance for the Cardinals organization. Getting Winquest back adds another layer of pitching depth, which is always valuable over the course of a long season.
Injuries, performance fluctuations, and the general unpredictability of pitching staffs make depth a crucial component for any team, and the Cardinals effectively regain a player they had not intended to lose in the first place.
It’s worth noting that the Cardinals likely viewed Winquest as a developmental piece rather than an immediate contributor when they first had him in their system.
His return simply restores that original plan. Now back under their guidance, the organization can continue to work with him on addressing his weaknesses, particularly his command and consistency. If he can make the necessary adjustments, there remains a pathway for him to eventually contribute at the major league level.
MORE: Angels cut ties with 0.45 ERA breakout ace after complete rebuild
Looking ahead, Winquest’s future will largely depend on his ability to adapt and improve. The raw talent that made him an intriguing Rule 5 selection in the first place has not disappeared. However, translating that potential into consistent performance is the challenge he must overcome. Refining his control, limiting walks, and regaining his ability to suppress hard contact will be key areas of focus.
The Cardinals, for their part, are in a phase where opportunities may arise for players who show progress and readiness. Over the next year or two, Winquest will have a chance to compete for a spot on the roster. While nothing is guaranteed, the organization’s current trajectory could provide openings for pitchers who demonstrate growth and reliability.
If he can put everything together, there is a realistic possibility that Winquest could make his way to St. Louis before the 2027 season. That timeline gives him ample opportunity to develop, adjust, and prove that he can handle higher levels of competition. It also aligns with the typical progression for pitchers who require additional seasoning in the minor leagues before making the leap to the majors.
MORE: Mariners Officially Make Roster Move After Recent Setback
In the end, Winquest’s brief tenure with the Yankees serves as a reminder of both the opportunities and challenges presented by the Rule 5 Draft. For players, it can be a chance to accelerate their careers and reach the major leagues sooner than expected. For teams, it represents a calculated gamble—one that can sometimes pay off, but also carries the risk of having to reverse course if things don’t work out.
For Winquest, the experience may ultimately prove beneficial. Even though he did not make a major league appearance with the Yankees, he gained exposure to a new organization, faced higher expectations, and had the chance to test himself in a different environment. Now back with the Cardinals, he can apply those lessons as he continues his journey.
While this move may not dominate headlines, it quietly reinforces an important aspect of baseball: player development is rarely a straight path. Setbacks, transitions, and second chances are all part of the process. For Cade Winquest, returning to the Cardinals represents another step in that journey—one that still holds the potential for a future breakthrough if he can capitalize on the opportunity in front of him.
Be the first to comment