The St. Louis Cardinals have identified their bullpen as an area of concern during the early portion of the season, and the organization has already begun taking steps to address the issue. In response to inconsistent performances from their relief corps, the team made a roster adjustment on Monday aimed at reshaping its pitching depth and potentially stabilizing late-game situations.
As part of the move, the Cardinals opted to bring in a fresh arm from the minor leagues, promoting 27-year-old right-handed pitcher Ryan Fernandez to the major league roster. At the same time, they made the decision to part ways—at least temporarily—with 27-year-old left-handed pitcher Jared Shuster, designating him for assignment. This transaction reflects the club’s urgency to improve its bullpen production and evaluate alternative options that might better suit their current needs.
The official announcement from the team confirmed both sides of the roster shuffle. In a brief statement, the Cardinals noted that Fernandez had been recalled from their Triple-A affiliate in Memphis, signaling their confidence in his readiness to contribute at the highest level. Meanwhile, Shuster’s designation for assignment indicates that the organization is willing to risk losing him to another team or reassigning him within the system if he clears waivers.
This move underscores a broader theme that has been developing for St. Louis early in the campaign. Bullpen struggles can quickly derail a team’s momentum, particularly in tightly contested games where relief pitchers are expected to preserve leads or keep deficits manageable. For the Cardinals, the inconsistency from their relievers appears to have reached a point where immediate action was deemed necessary.
By promoting Fernandez, the team is effectively giving him an opportunity to prove that he can provide more reliability and effectiveness out of the bullpen. While he may not yet have an extensive track record at the major league level, his performance in Triple-A likely demonstrated enough promise to earn this call-up. Organizations often turn to players like Fernandez in hopes that a fresh perspective and renewed energy can help shift the dynamic within a struggling unit.
MORE: “Absolutely Sad” Red Sox Lose 26-Year-Old Best Slugger
On the other side of the transaction, Shuster’s designation for assignment represents a significant turning point in his tenure with the team. Being DFA’d does not necessarily mark the end of his time with the organization, but it does place him in a vulnerable position.
The Cardinals now have a limited window to either trade him, release him, or attempt to pass him through waivers in order to retain him in the minor leagues. It’s a move that highlights both the competitive nature of roster construction and the difficult decisions teams must make when performance does not meet expectations.
These kinds of roster adjustments are not uncommon, especially early in the season when teams are still trying to identify the most effective combinations of players. However, they do carry a level of urgency when they involve the bullpen, given how crucial relief pitching is to overall team success. A reliable bullpen can be the difference between winning and losing close games, and teams with postseason aspirations often prioritize stability in this area.
For the Cardinals, this change could be just the beginning of further adjustments if the bullpen does not show signs of improvement. Front offices are constantly evaluating performance metrics, matchups, and situational effectiveness when deciding how to structure their pitching staff.
If Fernandez performs well, he could solidify his role and become a key contributor moving forward. Conversely, if the struggles persist, additional moves may follow as the team continues to search for solutions.
MORE: Mets Officially Cut Ties With Veteran Reliever in Surprise Move
The timing of the decision also suggests that the organization is not willing to wait too long before addressing evident weaknesses. Early-season games, while sometimes viewed as less critical, still count in the standings, and falling behind due to bullpen issues can create long-term challenges. By acting now, the Cardinals are attempting to prevent further damage and keep themselves competitive as the season progresses.
It’s also worth noting that these moves can have ripple effects throughout the organization. Promotions and designations for assignment impact not only the players directly involved but also others within the minor league system who may now have opportunities to step into larger roles. In this case, Fernandez’s promotion opens a spot in Memphis, while Shuster’s situation could lead to further roster adjustments depending on how things unfold.
Ultimately, this transaction reflects a proactive approach by the Cardinals’ front office. Rather than allowing bullpen struggles to linger unchecked, they have chosen to make a decisive change in hopes of improving performance. Whether this particular move will yield the desired results remains to be seen, but it clearly signals the team’s commitment to addressing its weaknesses and striving for better outcomes on the field.
As the season continues, all eyes will be on how Fernandez handles his opportunity and whether the bullpen as a whole can turn things around. At the same time, Shuster’s future will be closely watched, as he navigates the uncertainty that comes with being designated for assignment. For now, the Cardinals are focused on finding the right mix of talent to stabilize their pitching staff and put themselves in a stronger position moving forward.
Ryan Fernandez Should Give St. Louis A Boost
Ryan Fernandez has accumulated a fair amount of major league experience over the past two seasons, appearing in a combined 94 games at the highest level. His performance in 2025, however, left much to be desired on the surface. Over the course of 32 appearances that year, he posted a 7.71 earned run average, a figure that clearly reflects struggles with consistency and effectiveness.
For most observers, an ERA that high would immediately raise concerns about a pitcher’s reliability and ability to handle high-leverage situations. It suggests that opposing hitters were able to find success against him with relative ease, leading to runs that ultimately hurt his team.
Despite those struggles, there were still some underlying indicators that offered a more nuanced perspective on his performance. Notably, Fernandez recorded 34 strikeouts in just 30 1/3 innings pitched during the 2025 campaign. That level of strikeout production demonstrates that his raw stuff—his pitches, velocity, and movement—remained capable of overpowering hitters at times.
Strikeouts are often seen as a strong indicator of a pitcher’s potential because they eliminate the possibility of balls being put in play and turning into hits. In Fernandez’s case, the ability to generate swings and misses suggests that his struggles may have stemmed from issues such as command, control, or situational pitching rather than a complete lack of talent.
MORE: Diamondbacks Made Another Addition, Signed Right-Handed Pitcher
Looking back to the previous season provides even more reason for optimism. In 2024, Fernandez delivered a much stronger and more consistent performance across a larger sample size. He appeared in 62 games that year and finished with a 3.51 ERA, a mark that is generally considered solid for a relief pitcher.
That level of effectiveness indicates that he was able to limit damage, keep runs off the board, and contribute positively to his team’s bullpen efforts. It also highlights his durability and reliability, as making over 60 appearances in a season is no small feat for a reliever.
The contrast between his 2024 and 2025 seasons is quite stark, but it also helps illustrate why there is still belief in his potential. Teams often look beyond a single down year, especially when a player has already demonstrated the ability to succeed at a high level. In Fernandez’s case, his 2024 performance serves as proof that he can be an effective bullpen arm when he is at his best. That earlier success is likely what influenced the decision to give him another opportunity, as it suggests that his struggles in 2025 may not be permanent.
This belief in a possible rebound is central to the decision to bring him back into the fold. The hope is that Fernandez can rediscover the form he showed during his stronger season and once again become a dependable option out of the bullpen. If he is able to make the necessary adjustments—whether that involves refining his command, improving pitch selection, or simply regaining confidence—he could play a meaningful role in stabilizing a relief corps that has been dealing with its own set of challenges.
Encouragingly, his recent performance at the Triple-A level provided a glimpse of that potential turnaround. Before earning his promotion, Fernandez spent time pitching in Memphis, where he appeared in six games.
MORE: Angels cut ties with 0.45 ERA breakout ace after complete rebuild
During that stretch, he was highly effective, not allowing a single earned run. Such a performance is a strong indication that he was able to execute his pitches effectively and keep opposing hitters in check. For a pitcher trying to work his way back to the majors, stringing together scoreless outings is an important step in rebuilding confidence and demonstrating readiness.
In addition to preventing runs, Fernandez also showed an ability to miss bats during his time in Triple-A. Over 5 2/3 innings pitched, he recorded six strikeouts, continuing the trend of strong strikeout numbers that he displayed in the majors. This combination of run prevention and strikeout ability is exactly what teams look for in a reliever, as it suggests both effectiveness and the potential to handle pressure situations.
Overall, while Fernandez’s 2025 season may raise some concerns at first glance, a deeper look reveals reasons for optimism. His track record from 2024, combined with his recent success in Triple-A, suggests that he still possesses the tools necessary to contribute at the major league level. If he can build on that momentum and carry it into his current opportunity, there is a realistic chance that he could once again become a valuable piece in the bullpen.
Jared Shuster‘s Struggles
Jared Shuster’s most recent stint in the major leagues was brief, as he appeared in just two games for the St. Louis Cardinals before the organization decided to designate him for assignment on Monday. During that limited opportunity, he logged a total of 3 2/3 innings on the mound. Over that stretch, he surrendered two earned runs and issued a pair of walks.
While those numbers don’t necessarily jump off the page as disastrous, they also don’t provide much reassurance, especially given the extremely small sample size. Still, the decision to move on from him was less about those few innings alone and more about the broader struggles the Cardinals have been dealing with in their bullpen early in the season.
At this point in the year, St. Louis found itself in a difficult position when it came to relief pitching. Entering play on Monday, the team’s bullpen ranked near the bottom of the league, sitting 25th overall with a collective earned run average of 5.31. That figure is far from competitive by modern standards, particularly for a team that hopes to stay relevant over the course of a long season.
Even if the Cardinals are not widely viewed as a serious World Series contender in 2026, maintaining a respectable level of performance is still essential. A bullpen ERA north of five simply isn’t sustainable for a club that wants to remain in the mix or build momentum as the season progresses.
Because of these ongoing issues, the front office clearly felt that a change was necessary. Bullpen performance can often be volatile, but when struggles persist across multiple games and pitchers, teams are usually forced to act.
MORE: Mariners Officially Make Roster Move After Recent Setback
In this case, Shuster became the odd man out as the Cardinals looked for ways to reshuffle their relief corps and hopefully spark improvement. Moves like this are not uncommon early in the season, especially when organizations are still trying to evaluate their roster and determine which arms can be relied upon in high-leverage situations.
With Shuster now designated for assignment, his immediate future is uncertain. Other teams across Major League Baseball will have the opportunity to claim him off waivers if they believe he still has potential to contribute at the big league level.
Given his pedigree and prior experience, it wouldn’t be surprising if another organization took a chance on him, particularly one in need of left-handed pitching depth. On the other hand, there is also the possibility that he goes unclaimed. If that happens, he could remain within the Cardinals’ organization, likely continuing his career in the minor leagues as depth, or the team could ultimately decide to part ways with him entirely.
Looking at the bigger picture, Shuster brings with him a moderate amount of experience at the major league level. Over the course of four seasons, he has appeared in 64 games and compiled a 5.26 ERA.
Those numbers suggest a pitcher who has struggled to consistently find success against big league hitters, though they also indicate that he has been given multiple opportunities to prove himself. For teams evaluating him now, the question will be whether there is still untapped potential that can be unlocked with adjustments or a change of scenery.
From the Cardinals’ perspective, this move represents an attempt to address a glaring weakness rather than a definitive solution. Bullpen issues are rarely fixed by a single transaction, and it will likely take a combination of improved performances, strategic decisions, and possibly additional roster moves to bring the unit back on track. Nonetheless, making a change—any change—can sometimes serve as a catalyst, signaling both urgency and accountability within the clubhouse.
Despite their bullpen struggles, the Cardinals have managed to hold their own in the standings so far. With an 8-7 record, the team has shown flashes of competitiveness and resilience.
That record suggests they are not far off from being a more formidable club, especially if they can stabilize their relief pitching. Close games often hinge on bullpen effectiveness, and turning that area from a liability into even an average unit could have a significant impact on their overall performance.
There is still plenty of season left for St. Louis to turn things around. Early struggles, while concerning, do not necessarily define a team’s trajectory. If the bullpen can improve—even incrementally—the Cardinals could find themselves in a much stronger position as the year unfolds. In that sense, designating Shuster for assignment is just one step in what will likely be an ongoing process of evaluation and adjustment.
Ultimately, the decision underscores the importance of adaptability in baseball. Teams must constantly assess their roster and be willing to make tough calls in pursuit of better results. While Shuster’s time with the Cardinals may be coming to an end, the move reflects a broader commitment by the organization to address its shortcomings and strive for a higher level of play.
Be the first to comment