San Francisco Giants trade news. The St. Louis Cardinals appear to be standing at the beginning of a significant organizational shift this offseason, one that suggests the franchise is preparing for a retooling phase—or possibly a full-scale rebuild—after years of striving to remain competitive in the National League. While the Cardinals have historically avoided extended rebuilds, recent moves indicate a willingness to prioritize long-term flexibility and prospect capital over immediate contention.
That direction became unmistakably clear when St. Louis elected to move two of its most recognizable veterans, right-handed starter Sonny Gray and catcher Willson Contreras, in a trade with the Boston Red Sox. In return, the Cardinals received a package centered around younger talent and future assets, signaling a clear pivot away from the established core that had defined the club over the past several seasons.
Trading both Gray and Contreras was not simply about payroll relief or roster reshuffling—it represented a philosophical reset. Gray, despite his age, had been one of the Cardinals’ more reliable starters, while Contreras brought both offensive production and leadership behind the plate. Moving both players in one offseason strongly suggests the front office is prepared to absorb short-term growing pains in exchange for long-term upside.
With those trades complete, industry observers believe St. Louis is far from finished. The Cardinals still possess several players with meaningful trade value, and rival executives are closely monitoring whether the organization will continue selling established talent in the weeks ahead. One such player drawing increasing attention is utility standout Brendan Donovan.
According to Tim Kelly of Bleacher Report, Donovan stands out as one of the most intriguing potential trade pieces remaining on the Cardinals’ roster. Kelly recently identified Donovan as a strong candidate to be moved and highlighted the San Francisco Giants as a particularly logical destination should St. Louis decide to part with him.
MORE: Atlanta Braves news trade rumors, confirmed to land Blue Jays fan favorite
Donovan’s appeal begins with his versatility. Few players in baseball offer the positional flexibility he brings, and that adaptability alone makes him attractive to teams seeking lineup balance and roster efficiency. Over the course of his career, Donovan has logged significant innings at second base, first base, and left field, while also proving capable of filling in at additional spots when needed. That kind of multi-positional competence is increasingly valuable in a league that prizes adaptability and depth.
Kelly emphasized that versatility as a key factor in Donovan’s trade value. A team acquiring him could do so with the intention of penciling him in as its everyday second baseman on Opening Day, all while knowing he could seamlessly shift elsewhere on the diamond if injuries or roster changes demanded it. That flexibility allows a front office to solve multiple problems with a single acquisition, a luxury that becomes especially important over the course of a 162-game season.
Beyond his glove, Donovan’s offensive profile further strengthens his case as a desirable target. He is not a prototypical power hitter, but his approach at the plate is built around contact, discipline, and consistency. Donovan routinely puts the ball in play, limits strikeouts, and demonstrates an advanced understanding of the strike zone. That skill set enables him to contribute offensively regardless of where he hits in the batting order.
Because he does not rely solely on home runs for value, Donovan can function effectively in numerous lineup spots. He can serve as a table-setter near the top of the order, grind out at-bats in the middle, or provide situational hitting lower down. Kelly noted that this adaptability makes him an easy fit for virtually any manager, regardless of lineup philosophy or team construction.
Interestingly, Kelly’s analysis referenced college coach Tony Vitello when discussing Donovan’s ability to fit anywhere in a lineup, underscoring just how universal Donovan’s skill set is. Whether managed at the collegiate level or in the professional ranks, players who combine contact ability, plate discipline, and defensive versatility tend to earn trust quickly.
MORE: Braves pitching roster update connected to Diamondbacks All-Star right-hander to pair with Spencer Strider and Chris Sale
For the San Francisco Giants trade news in particular, Donovan checks multiple boxes. San Francisco has long valued players who can move around the field, a necessity given the organization’s frequent use of platoons and matchup-based lineups. Adding a player like Donovan would give the Giants a reliable option at second base while also providing coverage in the corner outfield positions.
From a roster-construction standpoint, Donovan could stabilize the Giants’ infield defense while also lengthening the lineup. His presence would allow the club to be more creative with matchups and provide insurance against injuries—an unavoidable reality over a full season. Few players offer that kind of day-to-day dependability without demanding a star-level role.
Defensively, Donovan has proven himself capable in both the infield and outfield. His instincts, preparation, and baseball IQ allow him to transition smoothly between positions, minimizing defensive drop-off. While he may not win Gold Gloves at multiple spots, he consistently grades out as above-average and dependable, which is often exactly what contenders seek.
Offensively, Donovan’s bat profiles as one that can “stick” in the lineup. He may not headline a lineup card, but his on-base skills and contact-first approach make him a valuable connective piece between more power-oriented hitters. In an era dominated by strikeouts, having a hitter who can extend at-bats and apply pressure to opposing pitchers carries real strategic value.
MORE: Houston Astros bullpen trade rumors today, inks 3-year deal with right-hander
From the Cardinals’ perspective, moving Donovan would not be an easy decision. He is a known commodity, a clubhouse presence, and a player who embodies many of the traits the organization traditionally values. However, rebuilds often require difficult choices, and Donovan’s combination of team control, versatility, and consistent production likely means his trade value is near its peak.
St. Louis would almost certainly demand a substantial return for Donovan, particularly if multiple teams express interest. Prospects with upside, controllable young pitching, or a combination of both would likely be required to pry him away. While that price could be steep, it may align with the Cardinals’ broader goal of replenishing their farm system and aligning their competitive window with a younger core.
For San Francisco, paying that price could make sense. The Giants are in a position where incremental upgrades matter, and adding a player like Donovan could provide stability without blocking long-term development plans. His versatility ensures he would not become redundant even if younger players emerge, and his skill set complements a wide range of roster constructions.
MORE: “Rockies Minor Trade News” Padres Officially Sign Catcher
Ultimately, Donovan represents the type of player who may never dominate headlines but quietly improves any team he joins. For a Giants club seeking reliability, flexibility, and competitive at-bats, he could be an ideal fit. For the Cardinals, moving him could accelerate a rebuild that already appears to be gaining momentum.
As the offseason progresses, the league will be watching closely to see whether St. Louis continues reshaping its roster and whether San Francisco—or another contender—decides that Brendan Donovan is worth the investment. If a deal materializes, it would further confirm that the Cardinals are committed to a new direction and that Donovan’s well-rounded game remains highly valued across Major League Baseball.
Be the first to comment