Breaking: Reds keep perfect bullpen fit strike boldly and fill glaring late-inning need

As the 2025 MLB trade deadline nears, the Cincinnati Reds face a pivotal decision: stay the course and hope their current roster holds up, or make an aggressive move to address a clear weakness in their bullpen.

On the surface, Washington Nationals closer seems like an ideal solution. However, growing league-wide interest could spark a bidding war that prices him out of Cincinnati’s range.

The Reds have been linked to bullpen help since early in the season. While Emilio Pagán has performed admirably as a fill-in closer, there’s understandable concern about relying on a pitcher who lacks a track record of handling ninth-inning duties over a full season.

Inconsistency at the back end of the bullpen has been a recurring issue, and Cincinnati currently ranks 18th in the majors in bullpen ERA.

That’s why Finnegan, a 33-year-old right-hander, has become such an appealing trade candidate. He’s quietly delivered another solid year, posting 18 saves along with a 2.96 ERA and 1.24 WHIP.

Kyle Finnegan’s trade price could push Reds out of bullpen market

MLB Network insider Mark Feinsand reports that several playoff contenders — including the Reds, Mets, Phillies, and Blue Jays — are showing interest in Kyle Finnegan. That’s where things get tricky for Cincinnati.

As the trade market intensifies — which appears increasingly likely — the Reds could be edged out financially. Historically, the team has been cautious about overpaying for short-term rentals and reluctant to trade away top prospects. That conservative approach may put them at a disadvantage if more aggressive teams like the Mets or Phillies decide to go all in.

It’s a classic dilemma of ideal fit versus realistic opportunity. The coming weeks will be pivotal. If the Reds make a strong playoff push, their front office might be more willing to swing a bold move. But if they tread water or slip in the standings, giving up long-term assets for a short-term bullpen upgrade like Finnegan could prove too steep a price.

Cincinnati clearly needs bullpen reinforcements, and Finnegan could be a near-perfect solution — but only if the cost aligns with their philosophy. Otherwise, he could be the one that slips through their fingers.