The Cleveland Guardians over the past half-year, few names have surfaced in Major League Baseball trade discussions as consistently as Steven Kwan. The standout outfielder for the Guardians has been at the center of speculation dating back to last season’s trade deadline, when Cleveland ultimately decided to keep him rather than entertain offers.
That decision did little to quiet the chatter. In fact, as the offseason has unfolded, interest in Kwan has only intensified, with rival front offices carefully monitoring whether the Guardians might finally be willing to part with one of their most valuable position players.
Kwan’s appeal across the league is easy to understand. In an era increasingly dominated by strikeouts and power-first approaches, he represents a somewhat rare archetype: an elite contact hitter who combines plate discipline, speed, and world-class defense.
Over the first four years of his big-league career, Kwan has established himself not merely as a solid everyday player, but as one of the most dependable outfielders in baseball. He is already a two-time All-Star and has captured four Gold Gloves, an extraordinary defensive résumé for a player still early in his career. On top of that, Kwan remains under team control for two more seasons, making him far more valuable than a typical rental player available on the trade market.
Because of that control and his consistent production, any team hoping to acquire Kwan would need to make a significant offer. While many clubs would love to add him, the reality is that not all contenders are in a position to sacrifice established major-league talent or premium prospects. This dynamic has narrowed the pool of potential suitors, creating a scenario in which only teams with both competitive aspirations and organizational depth can realistically engage Cleveland in meaningful trade talks.
MORE: Phillies officially sign flash-in-the-pan Braves starter
One such team, according to a recent proposal from Bleacher Report’s Joel Reuter, is the Cincinnati Reds. Reuter outlined a hypothetical trade framework that would send Kwan to Cincinnati in exchange for right-handed starter Brady Singer, along with two intriguing outfield prospects: Rece Hinds and Hector Rodriguez. While purely speculative, the proposal is compelling because it aligns with the strategic needs and timelines of both franchises.
From Cincinnati’s perspective, adding a player like Kwan would represent a major step forward in solidifying their lineup. The Reds have spent the last few seasons attempting to build an offense capable of supporting their young core, but consistency at the top of the order has often been elusive. Kwan’s skill set is almost tailor-made for that role. His elite on-base ability and bat-to-ball skills would immediately stabilize the leadoff spot, giving Cincinnati a reliable catalyst at the front of the lineup.
That table-setting role becomes especially valuable when paired with a dynamic talent like Elly De La Cruz. De La Cruz’s explosive power and speed are maximized when there are runners on base ahead of him, and Kwan’s presence would significantly increase those opportunities.
Over the past few seasons, the Reds have struggled to consistently get traffic on the bases before their middle-of-the-order hitters. Inserting Kwan at the top could dramatically change that dynamic, allowing the offense to function more cohesively and apply constant pressure on opposing pitchers.
Beyond his offensive contributions, Kwan would also enhance Cincinnati’s defensive alignment. His Gold Glove-caliber work in the outfield would pair seamlessly with TJ Friedl, giving the Reds one of the more reliable defensive outfield combinations in the National League.
In a ballpark like Great American Ball Park—where fly balls can quickly turn into home runs—having elite defenders capable of tracking down balls in the gaps carries even greater importance. While Kwan is not known for prodigious power, the Reds’ home stadium has a reputation for boosting over-the-fence production, potentially allowing him to slightly elevate his slugging numbers without altering his approach.
MORE: Angels swipe career .315 minor league hitter from Giants in waiver claim
Reuter specifically noted that while power is not the defining feature of Kwan’s offensive game, it is also not a glaring weakness in Cincinnati’s environment. More importantly, Kwan’s value lies in his ability to put the ball in play, avoid strikeouts, and keep innings alive. Those attributes would complement Cincinnati’s existing roster rather than overlap with it, creating a more balanced and versatile lineup.
Of course, acquiring a player of Kwan’s caliber would not come cheaply, and that is where the Guardians’ side of the equation becomes especially intriguing. Cleveland has long been known for its ability to maximize pitching development and extract value from both established arms and younger talent. In this proposed deal, Singer would immediately address a key organizational need by providing stability and experience in the starting rotation.
Singer has already proven himself capable of handling a regular workload at the major-league level. While he may not profile as a true ace, his durability and ability to navigate lineups multiple times make him a valuable commodity, particularly for a Guardians team that often emphasizes pitching depth and efficiency. Slotting Singer into the rotation would give Cleveland a dependable veteran presence who could either anchor the middle of the staff or help bridge the gap for younger arms still finding their footing.
MORE: Cubs-Marlins officially comfirmed another blockbuster deal, per report
The inclusion of Hinds adds a very different, but equally intriguing, dimension to the return package. Few prospects in baseball possess the raw power that Hinds brings to the table. His ability to drive the ball to all fields and generate eye-popping exit velocities gives him one of the highest ceilings among young outfielders.
However, that upside comes with risk. Hinds has yet to fully refine his approach at the plate, and questions remain about his consistency and strikeout rates. For an organization like Cleveland, which has a strong track record of player development, Hinds represents the type of high-reward project that could pay enormous dividends if everything clicks.
Rodriguez, meanwhile, might be the most quietly valuable piece of the entire proposal. Often overlooked in prospect rankings, Rodriguez has steadily built a reputation as one of the more underrated young players in the game.
His well-rounded offensive profile, combined with improving defensive skills, gives him a legitimate chance to become an everyday major-league contributor. While he may not generate the same headlines as Hinds, Rodriguez’s steady progression and advanced feel for the game suggest a high floor, with the potential for even more if his development continues on its current trajectory.
MORE: Reds latest reunion facilitate trading Brady Singer
For the Guardians, acquiring both Hinds and Rodriguez would help replenish the outfield pipeline in the wake of a Kwan departure. Cleveland has historically been adept at turning young, controllable talent into productive big leaguers, and this pair would provide multiple pathways to future value. When combined with Singer’s immediate rotation impact, the overall return begins to look like a balanced blend of present and future assets.
The broader context of this hypothetical trade underscores the difficult decisions facing the Guardians this offseason. Kwan is not just a fan favorite; he is a cornerstone player who embodies the team’s identity. Trading him would signal a willingness to recalibrate the roster in pursuit of long-term sustainability rather than short-term continuity. At the same time, Cleveland’s front office has never shied away from making bold moves when the value proposition makes sense.
For Cincinnati, pulling off a deal of this magnitude would represent a clear declaration of intent. The Reds have spent recent seasons assembling a promising young core, but translating that potential into consistent contention requires strategic additions.
MORE: Philadelphia Phillies trade discussions land Twins catcher
Kwan fits that bill perfectly: a proven, controllable player who raises the team’s floor while still leaving room for growth. His presence would not only improve on-field performance but also provide a stabilizing influence for a lineup still learning how to win at the highest level.
Ultimately, whether or not such a trade ever materializes, the idea itself highlights why Steven Kwan remains one of the most fascinating names on the market. He is the kind of player whose impact extends beyond traditional box-score metrics, influencing games through defense, situational hitting, and relentless consistency. As long as the Guardians remain open to listening on offers, and as long as teams like the Reds believe they are one piece away from taking the next step, Kwan’s name will continue to circulate in trade rumors.
If Cleveland were to secure a package like the one Reuter proposed, they would be positioning themselves well for both the present and the future. And if Cincinnati were to land Kwan, the ripple effects could be felt throughout the National League Central. For now, the speculation continues—but it does so with good reason, because players of Steven Kwan’s caliber rarely become available without reshaping the competitive landscape around them.
Be the first to comment