The Seattle Mariners’ offseason has unfolded in a relatively quiet fashion, especially when compared to the flurry of activity seen across much of Major League Baseball. While some clubs have aggressively reshaped their rosters through trades and free-agent signings, Seattle has largely stayed on the sidelines, making only modest moves and leaving many observers wondering whether the organization has done enough to keep pace in an increasingly competitive American League.
What makes the Mariners’ subdued winter particularly concerning is not just the lack of additions, but the fact that the team has also lost important contributors from last season’s offense. The departures of Jorge Polanco and Eugenio Suárez have left noticeable gaps in the lineup, stripping away both experience and production.
Polanco provided versatility and switch-hitting ability, while Suárez brought power and run production to the middle of the order. Replacing that level of output is no small task, particularly for a club that already struggled at times to generate consistent offense.
Seattle did manage to bring back Josh Naylor, which helped stabilize the roster to some degree. Naylor’s return ensures that the Mariners retain a reliable bat capable of driving in runs and anchoring the lineup. However, even with Naylor back in the fold, it’s clear the team still has unresolved needs. The offense, as currently constructed, lacks depth and proven consistency, and that reality has fueled speculation that the Mariners may eventually need to make a bold move to supplement their lineup.
MORE: Orioles involes in 4-player blockbuster deal, finish offseason with bang
One such idea has been floated by Bleacher Report analyst Joel Reuter, who believes Seattle could address its offensive shortcomings by acquiring a familiar name connected to one of its biggest stars. Reuter has proposed that the Mariners pursue a trade for Tampa Bay Rays All-Star Yandy Díaz, a former teammate of Seattle outfielder Randy Arozarena. The logic behind the suggestion is rooted in both Díaz’s offensive profile and the Mariners’ current roster construction.
Under Reuter’s proposal, the trade framework would be relatively straightforward. Seattle would acquire Díaz, primarily to serve as its designated hitter, while Tampa Bay would receive two prospects in return: shortstop Nick Becker and catcher Josh Caron.
From Seattle’s perspective, the deal would represent a clear attempt to add an established, high-level hitter without sacrificing anyone from the major league roster. For the Rays, it would align with their long-standing approach of leveraging veteran talent to acquire younger, controllable players who fit their developmental model.
Reuter’s reasoning centers on how Seattle appears poised to handle its infield situation heading into the upcoming season. If the Mariners commit to using a mix of Cole Young, Ben Williamson, and Colt Emerson across second base and third base, they will be leaning heavily on youth and inexperience at key positions.
While that approach may pay dividends in the long run, it also introduces risk in the short term. Young players often face adjustment periods at the major league level, and inconsistent production from the infield would place even greater pressure on the rest of the lineup to carry the offensive load.
MORE: Orioles finish off explosive offseason with blockbuster trade for $300 million Tigers’ star
In this context, Díaz becomes an especially appealing option. With his bat installed in the lineup as the primary designated hitter, Seattle could create a ripple effect that improves overall roster balance. Reuter envisions outfielder Dominic Canzone shifting into a more regular role in right field following his breakout 2025 campaign.
Meanwhile, Victor Robles would slide into a fourth outfielder role, providing depth and defensive flexibility. Díaz, in turn, would slot neatly into the DH spot, allowing the Mariners to maximize his offensive impact without worrying about defensive limitations.
From a purely statistical standpoint, Díaz’s 2025 season underscores why he would be such a valuable addition. Over 150 games, he posted a .300 batting average, a .366 on-base percentage, and a .482 slugging percentage, good for an .848 OPS.
He also recorded 29 doubles, 25 home runs, and 83 runs batted in, numbers that reflect both consistency and power. Those totals would represent a significant upgrade for a Mariners lineup that too often relied on home runs while struggling to sustain rallies through consistent contact.
Beyond the raw numbers, Díaz offers qualities that Seattle has sorely lacked in recent years. He is an elite contact hitter with a disciplined approach at the plate, capable of working deep counts and consistently putting the ball in play. That skill set would complement the Mariners’ existing power hitters and help diversify the offense. Rather than relying solely on feast-or-famine swings, Seattle could benefit from Díaz’s ability to reach base and keep innings alive.
MORE: Diamondbacks roster flexibility move, confirmed minor league deal
Adding Díaz would also solidify the core of the Mariners’ offense. A lineup anchored by catcher Cal Raleigh, superstar outfielder Julio Rodríguez, Arozarena, and Díaz would give Seattle a formidable group of hitters capable of competing with any team in the American League.
Each player brings a different strength to the table—Raleigh’s power from behind the plate, Rodríguez’s five-tool brilliance, Arozarena’s postseason pedigree and energy, and Díaz’s steady, professional at-bats. Together, they would form a balanced offensive nucleus that could support the development of younger players elsewhere on the roster.
Financially, the move also makes sense for the Mariners. Díaz is currently playing on a one-year, $12 million contract that includes a conditional club option for $10 million in 2027. For a player of his caliber, that level of commitment is relatively modest, particularly when compared to the escalating prices seen in free agency.
Even looking ahead, Díaz is projected to command something in the range of a two-year, $33 million deal after his current contract expires—still a reasonable figure for a hitter who consistently posts strong on-base and slugging numbers.
From Tampa Bay’s perspective, trading Díaz would not be without risk, but it would align with the organization’s long-standing philosophy. The Rays have repeatedly shown a willingness to move established veterans when they believe the return justifies it, especially if it allows them to restock their farm system and maintain long-term flexibility.
Acquiring Becker and Caron would give Tampa Bay additional depth at premium positions, and the Rays’ track record suggests they could maximize the value of such prospects through development.
MORE: Braves official transactions land superstar righty
For Seattle, the urgency of making a move like this cannot be overstated. The Mariners find themselves at a crossroads: their pitching remains strong, and their young position players offer promise, but the window to contend is not limitless.
Standing pat risks wasting another season of elite pitching and prime years from stars like Rodríguez. Making a calculated trade for Díaz would signal a clear commitment to winning now, while still preserving much of the organization’s future.
Ultimately, the proposed deal represents the kind of proactive, targeted move that could elevate the Mariners from a fringe contender to a legitimate threat.
Díaz would not only replace some of the production lost with Polanco and Suárez but would also add a new dimension to the offense—one built on consistency, discipline, and balance. For a team that has too often struggled to string together quality at-bats, that kind of addition could be transformative.
Whether Seattle’s front office ultimately decides to pursue this path remains to be seen. However, the logic behind the idea is compelling. A trade for Yandy Díaz would address a clear need, fit comfortably within the team’s financial structure, and enhance the lineup in both the short and long term.
One can only hope that the Mariners recognize the opportunity in front of them and take the initiative to explore negotiations, because moves like this are often the difference between simply competing and truly contending.
Be the first to comment